Interesting debate about authenticity.
As far as the Cable goat is concerned I own a 2009 model in a size 42 and it's a very nice jacket and quite close to originals. There is something about the body pattern of the Cable goat and the latest horshide offering that doesn't seem right. Judging by the Cables I have seen/owned they were some of the most inconsistently stitched A-2s, with mis-matched pockets etc.. but Gary's jackets are very clean and perfect in comparison.
It is pleasing to to see horsehide used with that label as originals of that label are only in horsehide. It would be nice to see the new horse Cable having small nickle ring snaps as opposed to nipple ones. So much for total authenticity!
BTW, Tim I know what you mean about the ELC seal RW 27752 contract, which just doesn't compare with Peter's RW 27752 from JC.