• When you click on links to various merchants on this site and make a purchase, this can result in this site earning a commission. Affiliate programs and affiliations include, but are not limited to, the eBay Partner Network.

BK Roughwear 23380 Seal Liberty A-2 REVIEW

Brettafett

Well-Known Member
BK Roughwear 23380
Seal Liberty horsehide with medium brown knit and thread. I like the olive drab thread also, but I think medium brown is more authentic for this model.
BK RW23380 42L 012.jpg

Received this jacket a few months ago and have worn it on and off, as much as possible. This is a great jacket!
BK RW23380 42L 013.jpg

Probably my favourite Roughwear repro of all time (and I've had a FEW beauts!) It fits perfectly and to my eye at least, drapes and fits, like a WW2 A-2 should.
BK RW23380 42L 009.jpg

I have never seen an original 23380 in person, but I have seen other original RWs. I do know that BK has at least one original in their collection, and have tried to copy the details meticulously. To my eye, BK have nailed the 23380 perfectly.
BK RW23380 42L 006.jpg

Size is a 42 long (a bit more to the sleeves). At 5’11 72kgs/ 158 pounds, 40” chest and athletic build, this jacket is how I want an A-2 to fit.
I’ll call this a ‘classic’ WW2 fit, with a wee bit of room for a light layer. Not super trim, not at all baggy. Perfect lengths for me, so when I lift my arms, the cuffs don’t ride up to my elbows (also accounts for some loss of length, due to creasing over time).
BK RW23380 42L 002.jpg

Measurements (approx):
SHOULDERS - 18”
PIT TO PIT FRONT - 22”
PIT TO PIT BACK - 22.25”
SLEEVE, from shoulder to end of cuff - 26.5”
BACK LENGTH - 25.75”
BK RW23380 42L 007.jpg

I'm a big fan of BK's Liberty horsehide. One thing that frustrated me, was that I could not find a repro that was the same mid-brown chocolatey colour of so many originals I've seen (examples of originals RWs below). Generally find darker browns, or reddy seal browns, besides the russet shades.
Here, BK's Seal Liberty hits a home run! I love the colour and the grain/ character is outstanding. This mid-brown hue, appears just like of so many WW2 original A-2's I seen.
The hide simply oozes grain, and even though its still to be broken in properly, it already exhibits tons of character. This jacket is going to look incredible in a few years time!
RW ORIGINALS.jpg

Knits are nice and tight, and feel more robust than some other top-tier makers. Its hard to accurately show knit colour in the pics. This mid-brown knit matches the seal Liberty very well, ( I also like the slightly darker WW2 brown kit. Both appear WW2-accurate).
BK RW23380 42L 004.jpg

Talon Zipper, although not a original dead stock M-40 ‘Sunray’ Talon, is still a Talon and more than up to the job.
Stitching is impeccable, and workmanship is top notch.
BK RW23380 42L 005.jpg

I'll be holding on to this one. After numerous high-end repro A-2s; GWs, ELCs, etc… can honestly say, BK’s jackets are right up there with any of the above. These jackets come second to none!
 

mulceber

Moderator
Great review, Brett. You really bring out everything that's great about this contract. Even before you'd said anything, I'd noticed how nice the tone of the Liberty Seal is. Definitely some russet tones in there, which has got me wondering how my forthcoming BK Star repro is going to look with the Liberty Seal hide/wine red thread.

The other thing I noticed is you've done an awesome job forming that collar. You'll have to tell me what you do to get it to drape like that.
 

Brettafett

Well-Known Member
Its the same I think, very similar pattern... I asked for around an extra 1", bit more on the sleeves...
 

mulceber

Moderator
25" back and sleeve length is indeed standard on the 23380. ;) The Rough Wears didn't change much over time, as evidenced by the debate about whether McQueen's jacket in The Great Escape was a 27752 or 16159.
 

Smithy

Well-Known Member
One thing that frustrated me, was that I could not find a repro that was the same mid-brown chocolatey colour of so many originals I've seen

I wholeheartedly agree Brett. My favourite A-2 colours are also the chocolate shades.

That's one of the things I like so much about my old AVI Bronco is that it's that wonderful dark, milk chocolate shade. Even they now seem to have gone along with everyone else and their new ones look to be those very dark shades or very red.

Everyone likes chocolate ;-)
 
Top