I have a pair of At the Front boondockers and didn't treat them. The boots will get soaked but only in heavy rain for a longer period. For normal daily use they do fine and don't need any treatment IMO.Agreed ... the problem with keeping them as they are is that in a rain they become like sponges soaking up everything that lands on them from water to dirt and mud. Then they don’t hold up so well. Have you had that problem with them in the past?